Skip to content
San Fransisco Bay Bird Observatory
  • About
    • Our Story
    • Strategic Plan
    • FAQs
    • Staff
    • Board
    • Science Advisors
    • Accountability
    • Commitment to Racial Justice
    • Employment
    • Contact Us
  • Science
    • Science Projects
    • Issues Birds Face
  • Education
  • Events
  • Volunteer
  • News
    • Wingbeat Blog
    • Subscribe to e-News
    • In the News
  • Give
  • About
    • Our Story
    • Strategic Plan
    • FAQs
    • Staff
    • Board
    • Science Advisors
    • Accountability
    • Commitment to Racial Justice
    • Employment
    • Contact Us
  • Science
    • Science Projects
    • Issues Birds Face
  • Education
  • Events
  • Volunteer
  • News
    • Wingbeat Blog
    • Subscribe to e-News
    • In the News
  • Give

Picture Ask A Scientist

In March 2020, we started Ask A Scientist on our social media where we covered a different topic each week and invited people to ask questions. Click the topics below to learn more about them, then click the images on the right to see a few of the questions and answers we received!
California Least Terns

The endangered California Least Tern ranges from the Bay Area to the tip of Baja California. Historically, there were no breeding Least Terns in the San Francisco Bay except Monterey, but the creation of salt ponds provided suitable breeding habitat for them. We monitor a colony in Eden Landing – one of only 5 colonies in Northern California!

In March 2020, volunteers helped us place tern decoys at Eden Landing. The goal is to attract more endangered California Least Terns and encourage them to nest and form colonies at the site. This technique is called social attraction.

Two Least Tern decoys sitting on ground.
How do California Least Terns nest?
California Least Terns (Sternula antillarum browni) nest on large, flat, and mostly unvegetated areas near waters of the Pacific, including on sand dunes, bays, and lagoons. They make their nest in a simple scrape with minimal lining. The clutch size ranges from 1-4 eggs, but 2-3 eggs is most common. Males and females share incubation duties (which lasts ~3 weeks) and parental care.  They often establish dense nesting colonies, which allows them to work together to defend their colony against predators by dive bombing, and sometimes even pooping on them!  This defense can be relatively effective against single avian predators, but may be less so against groups of avian predators and mammals.
What is their migratory pattern/route?
California Least Terns breed from the San Francisco Bay through Baja California Sur, and are found at select locations within this range from April-August. At the end of the breeding season, they begin staging for migration south, sometimes congregating at locations that they don’t currently breed at. They winter on the Pacific Coast of Central and South America, though the exact locations are unknown at this time.
Why did they become endangered?
One of the main reasons for their decline was increasing disturbance by humans at sandy beaches, their most common breeding sites. People walked through colonies, accidentally stepping on eggs and chicks. Since Least Terns are very sensitive to disturbance by predators (which includes humans), they abandoned many of their former breeding sites. Increasing predator populations, especially gulls, corvids, skunks, and invasive red foxes, which are all well adapted to living with humans, caused many of the remaining colonies to have very low reproductive success. Lastly, overfishing and climate change may have contributed to large annual variations in fish abundance. Northern Anchovies (Engraulis mordax) are the highest quality food for Least Terns, and successful reproductive years for Least Terns often correlate with large local anchovy abundance. Therefore, the volatility of anchovy populations may have contributed to lower breeding success.
Why do they need shelters?
Least Tern chicks are semi-precocial, which means that they are born with their eyes open, covered with down, and able to walk and swim within hours of hatching! However, they remain at the colony and are fed by adults at least until fledging (gaining the ability to fly), and thus are vulnerable to predation during that time. Shelters, whether wooden A-frames or terra cotta ceramic tiles, provide chicks with a place to hide from predators. They are especially effective at protecting chicks from avian predators, and have been used to improve the chick survival of all three Least Tern subspecies since the 1980’s.

Thanks to SFBBO Plover & Tern Program Director Ben Pearl for answering these questions.

California Gulls

Did you know that California Gulls did not breed in San Francisco Bay until 1980? Prior to that, they only bred inland at saline lakes like Mono Lake. Now nearly 50,000 California Gulls come to breed in San Francisco Bay every spring. This will be SFBBO’s 40th year monitoring their population growth and movements.
These birds are predators and can eat the eggs and chicks of shorebirds like threatened Western Snowy Plovers, which is why monitoring their breeding is so important.
​

Want to hear more about the impact of gulls and the work that SFBBO is doing? Check out this KALW radio story that featured California Gulls at Mono Lake and San Francisco Bay.

California Gull sitting on ground with 3 eggs in nest.
Graph titled Estimated number of breeding California Gulls in the South San Francisco Bay, CA from 1980-2019. Red trend line shows large increase in number of breeding California Gulls.
California Gull sitting on ground with 3 eggs in nest.
Graph titled Estimated number of breeding California Gulls in the South San Francisco Bay, CA from 1980-2019. Red trend line shows large increase in number of breeding California Gulls.
Where do California Gulls breed in the SF Bay? Are there similarities to Mono Lake in the place they breed? 
California Gulls breed in South San Francisco Bay (south of the San Mateo Bridge). In the South Bay, they breed on islands and levees in the salt ponds or in dry salt pans, yes similar to Mono Lake (high salinity, brine flies). In the past, a few pairs have also been observed breeding on Alcatraz Island, which holds a large Western Gull breeding colony.
Do inland salt lakes like Mono Lake lose breeding population for the gains here? 
Great question. Interestingly, Mono Lake’s breeding gull colony (historically around 44,000 to 65,000) has been experiencing steep declines from its historic numbers down to approximately just 22,000 breeding gulls last year (2019). Researchers who study this population believe that this change may be due in part to the declining habitat quality at Mono Lake marked by invasive plant growth and other changes. The leading hypothesis for San Francisco Bay is that the gulls who initially started breeding in San Francisco Bay in 1980 originated from Mono Lake. It is unknown how much exchange has occurred since then. Increases in San Francisco Bay are not directly correlated with declines at Mono Lake. If gulls are continuing to move from Mono Lake to San Francisco Bay, it is not the only factor that is causing the declines at Mono Lake.
Do we know if any individual California Gulls have appeared in both the Bay Area and Mono Lake (or other Great Basin location)?
There have been a handful of gulls that were tagged in Mono Lake and then observed in San Francisco Bay. This occurrence is relatively rare. Gulls tend to keep breeding at the same site as long as that site remains suitable. If the site doesn’t support breeding, gulls will often settle at a site that is very nearby if it is available.
If the nesting sites at Mono Lake were secure, would gulls leave the Bay Area? Is restoration of salt pond in the Bay making more or less nesting habitat for gulls?
Oftentimes migrating birds show a high degree of “site fidelity” and return to where they were born, so they’ll probably keep coming here as long as there is suitable habitat, even in year when the nesting sites at Mono Lake are favorable.
Restoring to tidal marsh will reduce the nesting habitat in the long term. However, gulls are not currently limited by nesting habitat in the South Bay. There are many long stretches of levee that would make suitable nesting habitat, so they may shift to those areas as the restoration progresses. The factors that have limited population growth in recent years (since the peak count in 2013) are unknown.

Thanks to SFBBO’s Waterbird team for answering these questions.

​Habitat restoration

The transition zone between tidal marshes and upland areas is an ecosystem that many types of wildlife rely on, but much of it has been wiped out by urbanization in the Bay Area. SFBBO has been working to restore plant communities in these areas for nearly a decade. 
​
Invasive plants are an ongoing problem in many of our restoration sites because they often out-compete natives and reduce biodiversity. One of our goals is to promote a plant community that is not only abundant, but diverse. To track this goal, SFBBO’s Habitats team conducts seasonal plant phenology surveys at our restoration sites.
​

If you’d like to stay involved, keep an eye out for our photo spots along the trail at the Bair Island Wildlife Refuge in Redwood City. You can help us track plant community progression by taking pictures at these signs and sharing with us on social media.

Thanks to SFBBO’s Habitats team for answering these questions.

What plants are you putting in? 
Plant species that we focus on planting at Bair Island include coastal gumplant (Grindelia stricta), creeping wild rye (Elymus triticoides), saltmarsh baccharis (Baccharis glutinosa), saltgrass (Distichlis spicata), California buckwheat (Eriogonum fasciculatum), and western goldenrod (Euthamia occidentalis). We also seed around 20 species of annual natives such as California poppy (Escholzia californica), fiddleneck (Amsinckia menziesii), common yarrow (Achillea millefolium) and many others.
What invasive plant species occur at your sites?
The invasive species that we deal with most are slenderleaf ice plant (Mesembryanthemum nodiflorum), crown daisy (Glebionis coronaria), New Zealand spinach (Tetragonia tetragonioides), cheesemallow (Malva parviflora), stinkwort (Dittrichia graveolens), and many species of thistles (such as Italian thistle) and mustards. Most are annuals (meaning they flower and seed once per year before dying off), but some are also perennial (meaning they live longer than a year and may produce seed many times during its life). Most invasives we deal with tend to be annuals that grow quickly, produce a lot of seed, and can disperse great distances either by wind or by animals.
How can we help?
We co-host monthly volunteer events at Inner Bair Island with Peninsula Open Space Trust, so keep an eye out for those on POST’s Eventbrite page if you’d like to join us in the field after the Bay Area’s shelter in place has ended. We also take volunteers during the week, so feel free to reach out if you’d like to help us at our native plant nursery or in the field. Also if you have a yard or plot of land that you can plant on, gardens containing native California plant species can serve as important micro-habitats that help support native insects and birds. Just remember to keep them pesticide and herbicide free!
Besides providing habitat for wildlife, how do tidal marshes benefit the environment?
Plants found in tidal marshes prevent water pollution by filtering runoff before it reaches the water. These plant communities also help to slow storm surges which can prevent flooding, and their root systems can prevent the erosion of shorelines. Tidal marsh ecosystems  are also excellent at storing carbon dioxide, one of the greenhouse gases most responsible for climate change.
Bird Banding

Did you know that SFBBO runs one of the few year-round bird banding stations in the US? We band about 2,500 birds per year with unique ID tags that identify individuals when we recapture them. We can use this data to look at population trends and life history patterns of resident and migratory species over time. Some of our tagged birds have lived 11 years!

SFBBO uses banding data from the Coyote Creek Field Station to track population trends over time. For a 20-year period between 1999 and 2018, bird populations on average have been declining. This graph shows two population groups: resident species like the Song Sparrow and Common Yellowthroat, and neotropical migrant species like the Yellow Warbler and Wilson’s Warbler. Both populations groups are declining at similar rates, despite one group (residents) staying in the Bay Area year-round, and the other group (neotropical migrants) traveling hundreds of miles to winter in Central and South America.

Graph of Capture Rates: Neotropical Migrants vs. Resident Species. X-axis is of Year from 1999-2018 and Y-axis is of capture rate (birds per 100 net hours). Trend lines for both neotropical migrants and residents show downward trend.
Who do you see migrating through year after year, and what have you learned about route fidelity?
Common migrants at CCFS include White-crowned Sparrow, Golden-crowned Sparrow, Fox Sparrow, Yellow-rumped Warbler, Western Flycatcher, Hermit Thrush, Swainson’s Thrush, and Ruby-crowned Kinglet. We generally see the same species migrating through during spring and fall, though the number of individuals that pass through will vary from year to year. Some species, like the Swainson’s Thrush, only pass through CCFS during spring; they take a different migratory route south during fall. In addition, they have low site fidelity, so it’s rare for us to recapture a Swainson’s Thrush that we banded in a previous year. On the other hand, banded Hermit Thrushes come back to CCFS year after year. We will occasionally catch the same individual Hermit Thrush in the same net on the same day it was captured in a previous year!
What can we do to support increasing the resident bird populations?
Billions of birds are killed each year by flying into reflective windows and by feral and outdoor pet cats, so reducing your footprint in these areas will help your local bird species. Native plants are also an important resource for local bird populations, and will help support your local species throughout the year.
Are there species that have defied the general decline by increasing their populations? 
Are there any major increases/decreases in specific species that are particularly interesting?
Song Sparrows have done remarkably well over the past few decades - they are now consistently our top capture. Song Sparrows are generalists, so they can adapt to a variety of habitats, including human-disturbed and urban habitats. 
We have seen populations of some species like Loggerhead Shrike disappear completely from our area, and others like Warbling Vireo have declined to a fraction of their historic numbers.
What bird species did you band the most in 2019? How about the first year you started banding?
Two species are at the top of our capture charts: Song Sparrow & White-crowned Sparrow. 
In 2019 we banded 653 Song Sparrows and 257 White-crowned Sparrows. 
In 1997, the 1st full year with all of our current nets, we banded 474 Song Sparrows and 825 White-crowned Sparrows. 
In 1983, the 1st full year of banding at CCFS (but with far fewer nets than we have now), we banded 276 Song Sparrows and 390 White-crowned Sparrows.

Thanks to SFBBO Landbird Program Director Josh Scullen for answering these questions.

Snowy plovers

Since 2003, SFBBO has been monitoring these small ground-nesting shorebirds in the South Bay, where most Snowy Plovers in the San Francisco Bay are found. The Pacific Coast Population has been listed as a Federally Threatened “Distinct Population Segment” since 1993 due to habitat loss, human disturbance, and predation. The SF Bay population has averaged ~200 adults in recent years (almost 10% of the entire Pacific Coast Population). Fun fact: Snowy Plovers are polyandrous; males and females share incubation duties, yet males raise the chicks while the female starts a second nest with another male!

Snowy Plovers lay eggs directly on the ground in lined scrapes, so camouflage is important for nest success. Snowy Plovers select nest sites with oyster shells, which provide camouflage for adults, eggs, and chicks. Past SFBBO research has indicated that nest success may also improve when Snowy Plovers nest within Least Tern colonies, likely because Least Terns aggressively defend their colony from predators. SFBBO works closely with partners such as the US Fish & Wildlife Service to provide high quality habitat for both of these imperiled species!

If you want to help threatened Western Snowy Plovers, keep an eye out for our next Mud Stomp habitat enhancement event!​

How do YOU pronounce plover?
This is a great question! We here at SFBBO are 
plover (ploh-ver) rovers, while other biologists, like our friends at Point Blue Conservation Science, are plover (pluh-ver) lovers. There seems to be a 50/50 split, so feel free to pronounce it how you like!
How can we help protect 
Snowy Plovers?
You can help protect them by leaving dogs at home when visiting parks, refuges, and beaches where plovers breed, following signage and staying away from sensitive breeding habitat, and packing out trash to avoid attracting predators. You can also volunteer with us as a volunteer surveyor or docent, and join our volunteer events to improve their habitat. Lastly, you can support measures that provide funds to preserve and enhance their breeding habitat in the San Francisco Bay, which is composed exclusively of former salt production ponds.
Do we have a better potential for nest success with all the people, pups, and kites off the beaches?
Fewer people and dogs on beaches will potentially help breeding plovers, but could also cause issues if they nest in areas that are usually very busy. We have already heard that plovers in other regions are nesting in areas where they normally would not. Once shelter-in-place orders are lifted, plovers in these areas will face high levels of disturbance, potentially resulting in nest abandonment, egg trampling, or chick mortality. Although we don’t have to face this issue in the San Francisco Bay, as all of our plovers breed in former salt production ponds that are off limits to the public, we have noticed an increased amount of trespassing on restricted trails and onto sensitive breeding habitat.
As far as predation goes, who are the biggest threats to our local Western Snowy Plovers?
We have identified numerous predators of Snowy Plover adults, eggs, and chicks here in the South San Francisco Bay.  Based on our research, the most critical predators in our area are: 
Common Ravens, 
Northern Harriers, Peregrine Falcons, California Gulls, 
and Red Fox.

Thanks to SFBBO Plover & Tern Program Director Ben Pearl for answering these questions.

Colonial Waterbirds

What is a “colonial waterbird”? These are birds that feed or live on the water and breed in groups called colonies. Colonies can include one or multiple species. We have many types of colonial waterbirds in San Francisco Bay, including herons, egrets, cormorants, terns, gulls, and shorebirds. April-June are the peak of the breeding season, so it’s a great time to learn more about our local colonies!

SFBBO’s Colonial Waterbird Monitoring Program has been tracking the nesting behaviors of colonial waterbirds since the 1980s – all thanks to the efforts of citizen scientists. Volunteers adopt colonies to monitor throughout the season and the data they collect help land managers to protect habitats for birds and people. Some of our volunteers have been monitoring the same colony for over 20 years!

SFBBO monitors colonial waterbird colonies all around the Bay Area at a variety of sites. Some of the colonies are in more remote areas, but some of them nest in more urban habitats – including a colony in downtown Oakland!

What are the most common colonial waterbirds in the 
San Francisco Bay area?
Shrub nesters like Great Blue Herons, Great Egrets, Snowy Egrets, Black-crowned Night Herons are quite common. Ground nesters like Forster’s Tern, Caspian Tern, Least Tern (less common), and California Gulls are also found in the Bay area. Double-crested cormorants are also common nesters in multiple locations, including on the Bay Bridge!
Have you noticed any trends of species that are increasing or declining in numbers?
The California Gull breeding population has skyrocketed since they started breeding in SF Bay in the 1980s. Unfortunately, gulls are predators of the eggs & chicks of shorebirds. USGS research has documented declines in American Avocets & Black-necked Stilts, which may be caused by habitat loss, predation, and/or contaminants. SFBBO found that populations of breeding Caspian & Forster’s Terns have also declined in the South Bay since the 1980s. One conservation success story has occurred with Double-crested Cormorants, which have increased greatly since near population collapse in the 19th century & 1950s–70s due to disturbance, overfishing by humans, and egg shell thinning from DDT.
What are the advantages of living, feeding, or nesting in colonies (especially multi-species colonies)?
Colonial nesting can provide protection from predators; more numbers are available to detect predators, and individuals can work together to mob and drive them off. Colonial nesting can also cause “predator saturation”, in which colonies reproduce in synchrony and predators are unable to take advantage of the sudden peak of prey resources. Other benefits to colonial nesting include access to information networks regarding foraging sites and opportunities. Nonetheless, nesting and living in colonies has drawbacks that range from predation within the colony to higher parasitic loads and susceptibility to spreading disease from living in close quarters.

Thanks to SFBBO’s Waterbird team for answering these questions.

Habitat Gardening

Urban development of the Bay Area has caused historically widespread habitats to be fragmented into smaller separated areas. As these areas shrink, the resources needed to support native animals are depleted, causing population declines and increased stress on ecosystems. Fortunately, there are ways for us to help – native gardens can help alleviate the loss of habitat by providing small areas of respite for the animals that need it most.

Here are some California native plants for your backyard bird sanctuary:
1. Pink flowering currant (Ribes sanguineum var. glutinosum) is a shrub that draws in hummingbirds with its flowers and attracts thrushes, quail, towhees, robins, and finches with its berries.
2. Twinberry (Lonicera involucrata) is a shrub that attracts hummingbirds when blossoming and robins, Wrentits, towhees, thrushes, Western Bluebird, and Chestnut-backed Chickadee when fruiting.
3. *Habitat Ecologist favorite* California sagebrush (Artemisia californica) is a shrub with delicate fragrant leaves that provides excellent shelter for birds. It is also known to attract Rufous-crowned Sparrows.

Pink Flowering Currant
Photo by Mark Robinson
Twin Berry
Photo by Melinda Stuart
California Sagebrush
Photo by Phillip Brouchard
What chemicals are bird-safe for cleaning the bird bath?
The safest cleaning solution for a bird bath is a diluted white vinegar mixture (9 parts water to 1 part white vinegar). If the bird bath needs a more thorough cleaning, soaking the basin with diluted bleach is acceptable as well. This will be bird safe as long as it is rinsed very thoroughly (!) and dried completely before refilling. Some commercial bird bath water treatments use harmless enzymes and bacteria to keep algae growth at bay as well.
Is there a soil that's best for native pollinators or is it species-specific?
For the most part it’s species-specific - native pollinators prefer different plants that can grow in a wide range of soils. Calscape.org is a great resource for finding native pollinator-friendly plants and the soils they prefer if you’d like to know more!
What plants do hummingbirds like?
Honeysuckle, twinberry, many types of monkeyflower, hummingbird sage, foothill penstemon, and fuschia-flowered gooseberry are all fantastic additions to a garden to draw in hummingbirds!
What will attract Cedar Waxwings to my yard?
Cedar Waxwings’ diet consists mainly of fruits (especially berries!) so your best bet would be native fruiting shrubs like holly leaf cherry or California blackberry, or native fruiting trees like manzanita, toyon, or Pacific madrone.

Additional design features and tips for your habitat garden:

  • Take it easy on the pruning! Mimic the features of a natural habitat by letting plants grow freely to provide more shelter and perches for birds
  • Provide a source of water. A water feature or bird bath will draw birds, especially during dry California summers. Keep the water clean and use bird-safe treatments if needed. – Keep your garden pesticide and herbicide free. Many of the chemicals found in them can be harmful or deadly to birds when ingested.
Thanks to SFBBO Ecologist Kaili Hovind for answering these questions.

Hermit thrush migration

Hermit Thrushes are one of North America’s favorite songbirds. Here in the Bay Area they are only winter visitors so we miss out on their lovely songs, which they save for their breeding grounds. In winter of 2012-2013 for her MS research, guest scientist Allison Nelson collaborated with SFBBO and Point Blue to deploy geolocators on Hermit Thrushes in Point Reyes and at CCFS to discover where these charismatic birds spend their summers.

She found a small-scale pattern of “leapfrog” migration in Hermit Thrushes, in which the southern (CCFS) wintering birds headed farther north than the northern (Point Blue) wintering birds. CCFS Hermit Thrushes migrated to the Alexander Archipelago of southeast Alaska and the adjacent British Columbia coast (shown in blue), and the Point Reyes birds migrated to sites farther south (shown in pink) near Vancouver Island, the island of Haida Gwaii, the British Columbia mainland, and the Olympic Peninsula of Washington

Map of Hermit Thrush Breeding Locations
Due to the Hermit Thrush's inconspicuous color pattern, are they hard to spot in their habitat when looking for them to band or collect data?
Yes, they are difficult to see! But during the breeding season the males sing conspicuously at dawn and dusk. In winter they are most often recognized by their quiet
What tools do you use in the field to tag and track bird migrations?
We used light level geolocators. The models we used, from Migrate Technology, recorded light levels every 1 minute and stored the highest light level from every five minute period, and time-stamped it. From this massive amount of data collected over approximately one year, you can use earliest and latest daylight recorded to estimate longitude, and day length to estimate latitude for each day.
Once you capture the targeted species, how do you actually band them? How long does the process take?
We attached aluminum USGS-issued uniquely numbered bands and Darvic plastic color bands, using unique pliers specifically designed for these tasks. Just placing a band on them takes probably less than 30 seconds, but if you are banding them, adding color-bands to help recognize individuals in the field, taking blood or feather samples for genetics work, taking morphological measurements, and attaching a geolocator, the bird may be captive for 20-25 minutes. We only took blood or feather samples on birds when we removed geolocators so as to minimize stress at the time of deployment, or from birds that weren't getting tags.
When is “peak” migration for Hermit Thrushes moving along the Pacific coast during fall?
Peak captures of Hermit Thrushes at Coyote Creek Field Station are in October. Other species, like Pacific-slope Flycatcher and Wilson's Warbler peak a bit earlier, especially those that migrate farther than Hermit Thrush, many of which stay in the Bay Area over the winter.

Thanks to Allison Nelson for answering these questions. Allison was a banding volunteer at Coyote Creek Field Station while doing her MS at San Francisco State University. She is now the founder & director of Gold Country Avian Studies in Nevada City, CA.

Avian disease prevention program

SFBBO has been conducting surveys in the South Bay as a part of the Avian Disease Prevention Program since 1982. We survey Coyote Creek (also known as Artesian Slough) and Guadalupe Slough in search of sick, injured, or dead birds (and other wildlife including fish and sometimes even mammals), which we remove from the waters to prevent avian botulism. Some of our surveys are conducted from a truck driven on the levees, but most are conducted by boat with volunteers, who have helped us survey the South Bay waters for over 30 years!

Avian botulism is a disease found in birds caused by a toxin released by the bacterium Clostridium botulinum. We most commonly find gulls affected with the disease, especially during warmer months.

Infected birds often die of starvation or drowning caused by a gradual paralysis where they have difficulty diving, flying, and keeping their head up. Most birds that contract the disease will die of it, but early detection is a strong tool for prevention and some birds can survive if they receive treatment.

Through our Avian Disease Prevention Program, SFBBO and volunteers work hard each year to prevent outbreaks by removing dead or sick birds and promoting healthy waterbird populations!

There must be all kinds of bird diseases. Is there something about avian botulism that makes it more of a concern?
One major concern about avian botulism is how rapidly it can be passed from bird to bird, and consequently how rapidly it can wipe out large numbers of birds. Large die offs of millions of birds have been observed in other parts of the world as a result of botulism outbreaks, so it is our goal to prevent any outbreak to the best of our ability.
Have there been any notable avian botulism outbreaks in recent years?
Since 1982, when SFBBO began surveying for the Avian Disease Prevention Program, there have been 6 large die-offs. The largest occurred in 1998 when over 1000 birds were found afflicted with the disease; another die-off occurred in 2004. Most recently, there was an outbreak in 2013 at the Tule Lake National Wildlife Refuge in Northern California near the Oregon border where over 40,000 waterfowl died, and a suspected outbreak in 2019 in the LA River.
What birds does avian botulism affect other than gulls?
The bacterium that causes avian botulism, C. botulinum, can be broken down into 7 strains (A through G), with types C and E most responsible for illness or death in birds. Type C most often affects waterfowl such as ducks or geese, while Type E commonly affects piscivorous (fish-eating) birds such as cormorants, gulls, pelicans, and grebes, but also some waterfowl such as scaup or mergansers.
Do all sick or dead birds get tested for bird diseases?
The birds we typically rescue that we suspect have botulism are not often tested for the bacteria as the symptoms of botulism are often diagnostic. However, if rehabilitation technicians suspect other illnesses, the birds may be tested. In general, birds taken into care are fed and rehydrated but may be treated with antibiotics if infections are suspected. Unfortunately, the birds we capture that are suspected of having botulism generally do not survive as they are usually found and captured in the late stages of the disease when most treatments are ineffective. While it isn’t always possible to detect botulism, the best we can do is remove dead or sick wildlife from the ecosystem to prevent possible outbreaks.

Thanks to SFBBO Habitats Program Director Cole Jower for answering these questions.

Spiders

Spiders are an important part of the ecosystem; many are keystone predators and a food source for birds and other animals.
​

In the transition zone between tidal marshes and upland areas, we can find: orb-weavers that construct elaborate webs between vegetation; funnel-web and cobweb spiders that construct sheet webs in soil or low in vegetation; and wolf spiders, sac spiders, ground spiders, and jumping spiders, which live under rocks and other debris.

Spiders produce silk made of proteins that are in liquid form within silk glands and solidify as the spider extracts it through spinnerets, specialized structures used to spin silk. Mixing of different types of threads allows spiders to create different kinds of silk used for various purposes, such as adding sticky droplets to make “capturing lines” in webs, transmitting vibration, dispersing, or wrapping fresh prey.

Some birds incorporate spider web fibers into their nests, where the webs may serve a structural role, attaching nest materials together or with surroundings. Webs may also serve as an insulator in the internal lining of the nest, or as a thermoregulator, reflecting solar radiation when it covers the exterior of the nest.

How does a spider produce its web?
It varies with the species of spider and with its foraging behavior. The silk is a fiber composed of proteins and is produced in glands located in the posterior of the abdomen. The glands are associated with appendices called spinnerets, through which different processes work to solidify the silk, which is then secreted and spun. For orb-web spiders in general, making the web begins with releasing of a silk thread (bridge thread) that anchors to one of the structures where the web is going to be attached. Spiders do this by pulling the silk with its fourth leg through the spinnerets. Afterward, other silk lines are made to anchor other structures, giving stability to the web. Then the spider begins to generate the radial lines (that go from the center to the outside), and then ends with orb lines, which spiral around the web, from outside to the inside.
How do spiders survive after a leg or foot injury?
Sometimes to escape predation or liberate a limb, spiders can sacrifice some appendages by mutilating them, generally from a joint closer to the body. This is called autotomy. As soon as the appendage is detached, the muscles and other structures (sclerites) present help to close the wound rapidly, restricting the loss of blood (technically hemolymph) and leaving a small hole that clots and finally seals. If the spider continues molting, it can then regenerate the lost limb.
Are there other important bird-spider interactions besides using webs in nests?
The principal interaction is that many spiders are a significant part of the diet of many birds. It has been estimated that 3,000 to 5,000 omnivorous bird species consume spiders, and during some periods, spiders can constitute 20-95% of their diets. It is probable that during those times, they are the most available prey. Also, some studies show that spiders are one of the principal foods in the nestling diet for some birds.
Would any animals eat a tarantula with all those nasty hairs?
Even with nasty but useful hairs, tarantulas have predators. Some animals, like hawks, owls, coyotes, foxes and some reptiles are capable of consuming them. Some wasps are specialized in parasitizing tarantulas. They paralyze and lay an egg on the spider's abdomen and when the larva hatches, it starts to consume the still-living tarantula.

Thanks to SFBBO Ecologist Yeimy Cifuentes for answering these questions. She studied tarantulas in Colombia. ​

Burrowing owls

Did you know that Burrowing Owls are the only species of owls nesting and roosting in underground burrows? In the Bay Area, these birds rely mostly on California ground squirrels to dig these burrows. When ground squirrels are absent, artificial burrows are sometimes installed as a temporary management tool.

Burrowing Owl populations have been declining throughout most of their range. Some factors for the decline include destruction of grassland habitat, lack of vegetation management, lack of prey, predation, and ground squirrel extermination. Ground squirrels are a keystone species for healthy grassland habitat and provide important ecosystem services.

SFBBO collaborates with Santa Clara Valley Audubon Society to conduct vegetation management for Burrowing Owl habitat. We hope to resume volunteer work days in the future, so keep an eye out!

​Thank you to Phil Higgins and Sandra Menzel for being our guest scientists and answering these questions.

What are some ways we can help Burrowing Owls?
Preserve grassland areas. In suitable grassland, vegetation height needs to be kept low. Don’t exterminate ground squirrels. Keep your distance from occupied burrows. If you observe disturbance to burrowing owls, report it to CalTip. We do sometimes have volunteer opportunities to help us with vegetation management in North San Jose. Work days are posted on SFBBO’s and Santa Clara Valley Audubon Society’s Facebook pages and websites.
How many breeding pairs are there in Santa Clara County?
The Santa Clara Valley Habitat Agency organizes annual surveys throughout the county, and in collaboration with Santa Clara Valley Audubon Society, Talon Ecological Research Group, and SFBBO, we have been monitoring only 13 nesting pairs this breeding season. Previous survey reports can be reviewed on the Agency’s website: 
www.scv-habitatagency.org/
DocumentCenter 
Each report contains information on population trends for the county since the late 1990s.
Do Burrowing Owls ever return to old nesting grounds?
Yes, Burrowing Owls have moderate to high nest-site fidelity, especially when they bred successfully. Some pairs are still nesting at Moffett Field every year. For her graduate studies, Sandra actually assessed nest-site fidelity (an individual occurring at the same location during successive nesting seasons) and natal philopatry (the tendency of an individual to stay in or return to its natal area) of Burrowing Owls raised in artificial burrows. The results of her research are published in this journal article: 
Menzel, S. (2018). Artificial Burrow Use By Burrowing Owls In Northern California. Journal of Raptor Research, 52:167-177.
Do Burrowing Owls produce pellets?
Yes, in fact, all owls do. Owls usually swallow their prey whole, and food passes directly from the beak to the gizzard. Tissues that cannot be digested include teeth, skulls, claws, and feathers. To excrete these materials, the owl's gizzard compacts it into a tight pellet that the owl regurgitates. Burrowing Owl pellets usually contain a high percentage of invertebrate remains.
Mono lake

Mono Lake is a “terminal”, or one with no outlet. This means its level is determined solely by tributary inflows, precipitation, and evaporation, and makes it highly susceptible to disruptions. As a naturally hypersaline lake, it is also an essential stop for migratory birds traveling across the Great Basin and along the Pacific Flyway.

In 1941, the Los Angeles Department of Water and Power (LADWP) began diverting water from the lake’s tributaries, resulting in severe ecosystem disruptions. In 1994, after decades of protest, research, and legal battles, the LADWP was forced to curtail its diversions and outline plans for local restoration, conservation, and monitoring programs. Many species at Mono Lake have since made spectacular recoveries, and the basin remains one of the most important birding hotspots in California.

Mono Lake’s most iconic natural landmark is its eerie, crumbling tufa towers! How are these bizarre structures formed? Where freshwater springs percolate through the lake’s naturally saline water and volcanically-enriched sediments, calcium in the freshwater combines with carbonate in the saline water. The resulting mix solidifies as the minerals age, ultimately forming tufa towers that can reach over 30 feet!

Tufa can also form via biogenesis, through the biological activity of organisms like the alkali fly. When an adult alkali fly emerges from its underwater pupae case, it leaves behind a tiny deposit of calcium carbonate that contributes (on a minute scale) to the growth of underwater tufa towers.

Why does Mono Lake smell funny?
Mono Lake is a “terminal” lake, or one with no outlet. Consequently, water is lost only through evaporation, increasing the lake’s salt content over time. In fact, Mono Lake is now 2-3 times saltier than the ocean! The lake’s natural salts combine with an abundance of ancient volcanic materials to create a unique mix of dissolved sodium salts, which include chlorides, carbonates, and sulfates. This odd chemical mix is what gives Mono Lake’s water its distinctive features, including its “slippery” feel, bitter taste, and bad smell.
How susceptible is Mono Lake to drought, and how does it affect the wildlife there?
Because Mono Lake’s level is determined by snowmelt, tributary flows, springs, and evaporation, it is highly susceptible to drought. Droughts can have enormous ramifications for the lake’s ecosystems and wildlife. They endanger the critical riparian and wetland habitats surrounding Mono Lake, disrupting local fisheries and bird life, and may result in exposure of the lake’s alkali flats, which can quickly lead to violent dust storms. Past droughts have also exposed a land bridge connecting Negit Island and surrounding islets to the mainland. These islands are critical nesting sites for migratory birds (mainly California Gulls), and the falling water table exposes their chicks and eggs to predation by local coyotes.
What were the major changes made that helped Mono Lake’s recovery?
Two major lawsuits paved the way for Mono Lake’s recovery. The 1st was filed in 1979 by the National Audubon Society; the CA Supreme Court ruled that the state had to protect places like Mono Lake “as far as feasible.” The 2nd lawsuit was filed by a coalition in 1984, suing LADWP on the grounds that their water diversions didn’t comply with state-mandated minimum fish flows. The two suits were combined and brought before the State Water Resources Control Board, which ruled in 1994 against LADWP. The ruling set minimum flows for Mono Lake’s tributaries, ordered LADWP to restore streams & waterfowl habitat, and established limits on future water diversions based on lake level. Since diversions were curtailed, life has rebounded. The lake’s water levels have risen, salinity levels have rebalanced, and riparian areas have recovered. Brine shrimp & alkali fly populations that form the basis of the food chain have re-established; bird life is thriving; trout have returned after decades of absence; and species like Osprey have expanded their ranges in the Mono Basin!
Are there naturalist tours at Mono Lake?
Yes! Large portions of Mono Lake are now protected as state natural reserves, scenic areas, and regionally-operated parks and recreational spaces, and there are many opportunities to take naturalist tours in these areas. The USFS Visitor Center has many interactive displays on Mono Basin’s geology, ecology, and human history, and rangers are present to answer any questions. The Mono Lake Committee also offers free, naturalist guided walking tours of Mono Lake, as well as summer canoe and kayak tours.

Thanks to SFBBO Science Outreach Intern Charlotte Diamant for answering these questions. She spent a semester researching the human and natural history of this remote alkaline lake located east of Yosemite National Park and near the Nevada border.

Butterflies

Butterflies are in the major insect order Lepidoptera, which contains butterflies and moths. Lepidoptera means “scaled wings”; wings are covered by tiny overlapping scales whose pigment and structure provide the colors that we enjoy. Butterflies are just a single branch of this large group. The number of moth species is about 15 times the number of butterflies, so many naturalists think of butterflies as a small group of colorful day-flying moths.

Butterflies have four distinct life stages: egg, larva (caterpillar), pupa, and flying adult. The stage that has the largest impact on the environment is the caterpillar, often called an “eating machine,” accumulating stores of proteins and fats that fuel metamorphosis. As a bag of nutrients, the caterpillar is a high-energy food source for birds and other animals, particularly parasitic wasps.

Adult butterflies can be easy to see as they fly through our neighborhoods and wild lands. Caterpillars are often seen by chance, although in the Bay Area, Variable Checkerspot caterpillars can often be found on a very common host plant, Sticky Monkeyflower, in the spring. In general, pupae are rarely seen because they are often well-camouflaged and don’t move. Even though eggs are very tiny pinhead-sized objects, with effort they can be located by looking for egg-laying behavior. Adult butterflies often will perch on plants for long time periods or fly from flower to flower sipping nectar. A female butterfly that flies from plant to plant, spending a few seconds and moving on but not nectaring, may be laying eggs that can be seen by carefully searching.

How are butterfly populations monitored?
Many counting protocols have been developed to count and monitor butterfly populations. The North American Butterfly Association (NABA) sponsors summer butterfly counts all across the country. Beyond general counting of adult butterflies, many other methods have been developed for monitoring butterfly populations. Some depend on characteristics of the particular species. For example, Monarchs can be counted at their wintering sites where they gather on or near the California coast. In our own area, the threatened Bay Checkerspot butterfly is monitored by counting caterpillars on the ground.  In addition, various tagging methods have been developed to monitor and track individual butterflies.
How many butterfly species exist worldwide and how many are endangered?
Worldwide there are ~160,000 moth species and ~17,500 butterfly species. In the US, there are ~750 butterflies species and 32 of these are threatened or endangered, including 6 in the Bay Area: 3 on San Bruno Mountain (Mission Blue, San Bruno Elfin, & Callippe Silverspot), the Lange’s Metalmark at Antioch Dunes, and the Bay Checkerspot on Coyote Ridge near south San Jose. 

The Xerces Blue was one of the first butterflies to go extinct in the US, last seen in 1941. It was a victim of habitat destruction, with the coastal sand dunes on the San Francisco Peninsula as its favored habitat. The invertebrate conservation organization Xerces Society takes its name from the Xerces Blue.
What are some ways tell apart butterflies from moths?
The most reliable character to separate moths from butterflies in the field is the antenna shape.  Butterflies have clubbed antennae, with a rounded knob at the antenna tip, although the skipper family has thickened antennae tips rather than clubs. Moth antennae are often thin and wire-like, or in some species outlandishly feathery and complex. Many moths have more robust and hairy bodies as adults. Most moths, although there are many exceptions, are out at night. Most adult moths at rest will have their wings extended outward, held out at the sides looking like a triangle from above, or held roof-like over their body, while most butterflies hold their wings together above their bodies.
How can we help local butterflies?
Habitat destruction and fragmentation have caused long-term declines of both birds and insects. Invertebrate wildlife also face many other challenges, such as pesticides, invasive species, and climate change. Let your elected representatives know that environmental protection and wildlife conservation is important to you. Support local organizations that protect habitat & wildlife, such as California Native Plant Society chapters, Audubon chapters, and SFBBO. Your yard or garden (especially with native plants & minimal pesticides) can also provide habitat & food sources for birds, butterflies, and other invertebrates. Check out the Xerces Society, a national organization devoted to invertebrate conservation including butterflies and our native pollinators.

Thanks to SFBBO Board member and volunteer Jan Hintermeister for answering these questions. He has watched butterflies and led butterfly hikes for 10 years. Why would someone interested in birds care about butterflies? On warm sunny afternoons when bird activity can be subdued, butterflies are at their peak. Many are easy to see and identify with colors that easily rival those of warblers, orioles, or tanagers. Butterfly caterpillars can be an important food source, particularly during the breeding season when even seed-eating birds turn to caterpillars to feed their young.

Bacteria

Today, there is a significant fear of these little bugs. It is important to understand that every single creature on our planet, including humans, depends on these single-cell organisms to survive and thrive. They are responsible for helping digest our food, strengthen our immune system, and even producing hormones. Our mood, health, and overall well-being depends on a delicate balance between pathogenic (bad) and beneficial bacteria, viruses, and fungi. Learning more about their mysterious world has led humans to fascinating discoveries and we are just scratching the surface in our understanding.

Did you know:

  • We have more bacteria living inside us than we have human cells.
  • Bacteria in our gut can affect our mood. Scientists have found that gut bacteria produce many neurotransmitters such as dopamine, norepinephrine, acetylcholine, and GABA, which are critical for mood, anxiety, concentration, reward, and motivation. The gut #microbiome can cause changes in how our brains react.
  • Bacteria in our gut can affect our cravings. Next time, think about who made the decision to eat that cookie!​​

How effective are the “probiotics” included in things like yogurt that are sold in markets these days?
There is still conflicting information on the efficacy of probiotics. Some experts believe that even highly potent probiotics of 15 billion colony-forming units (CFUs) will most likely not take residence and proliferate in our gut. Others believe that taking probiotics regularly with multiple strains and high CFU counts can help to shift the balance between beneficial and harmful bacteria in our gut. The consensus seems to be for taking a good prebiotic that feeds the good bacteria in our gut and helps them outcompete the bad bacteria. It is also very important to deal with the root cause of a disturbance first, such as bacterial or fungal infection or inflammation in the gut, before introducing probiotics.
What bacteria do you think is the most interesting?
I find most fascinating not the specific bacterium, but how bacteria function together and communicate. Quorum sensing is the ability of each bacteria to regulate genes based on the chemical signal secreted by other cells. By using quorum sensing, bacteria are able to regulate their population, recognize competing and synergistic species of bacteria nearby, produce protective biofilm and resistance to antibiotics for their colonies, and even alter chemical markers in the human genome.
Is there any part of our bodies that doesn’t have bacteria on or in it?
Technically, we do not expect to see bacteria in the blood, brain, heart, liver, kidneys, pancreas, spleen, lymph nodes, bones, and other internal fluids and tissues. However, harmless bacteria can sometimes be found in these tissues even in healthy individuals.
Is the 5-second rule a real thing?
That is a myth! The moment the food touches another surface it will be exposed to whatever is on that surface. Of course, the longer the food sits out, the more likely that bacteria and fungi in the air will multiply and spoil that food and make us feel sick.

Thank you to SFBBO Board Member Anastasia Neddersen for answering these questions.

San clemente island loggerhead shrike

The San Clemente Island Loggerhead Shrike is an endangered subspecies endemic to the most southern Channel Island of California. Since the 1980s, the US Navy has been working to recover this subspecies and restore the island ecosystem which includes other threatened & endangered species.

Loggerhead Shrikes are often called the “butcherbird” because they impale their prey on cacti or branches. This behavior is called caching. They wedge their food in the fork of branches to break up and eat prey that is almost as large as they are. It also allows them to store larger prey items to eat over a few days or feed to their chicks. Smaller food items like crickets might be impaled on barbed wire for morning snacks.

Watching a shrike kill a mouse or lizard is an art. Male shrikes demonstrate how to capture, kill, and cache mice for their juveniles. They learn to fly down, grab prey, and shake it just right to paralyze it and break its neck, and that prey can only be cached if it isn’t moving. Practice makes perfect for these tiny carnivorous birds!

What distinguishes the San Clemente Island Loggerhead Shrike from other subspecies?
San Clemente Island Shrikes are genetically differentiated from both the mainland and other island populations (Santa Catalina, Santa Cruz, and Santa Rosa). Migration between the Mainland – Santa Catalina – San Clemente occurs very rarely with nominal gene flow. Basically, this subspecies only lives and breeds on this island, so it is geographically isolated from all other shrike populations. The SCI Shrike is physically similar to the mainland Loggerhead Shrike except SCI Shrikes tend to be a slightly darker gray in color.
What made the San Clemente Island restoration and reintroduction program so successful?
There are many factors that made this recovery project a success. First is the funding and long term commitment of the landowner, the US Navy. Second is a restoration plan that includes adaptive management for whole-island ecosystem restoration and includes experts in the areas of captive breeding, behavior, avian monitoring/reintroduction, predator management, and plant restoration. Basically, this team of experts studied and customized most aspects of the recovery to this subspecies in its existing ecosystem. An example is that supplemental feeding of live prey to reintroduced birds was found to improve their overwintering and breeding success. However, the unique setting of the whole island being a military base means that it is controlled and maintained by the main stakeholder in the project which makes this a more closed system than most.
What are the greatest contributors to the endangerment of the San Clemente Loggerhead Shrike?
Humans, habitat loss, and predators. For over 100 years, the US Navy allowed farmers to graze goats on the island which decimated the native plant life and allowed non-native plants to flourish. This in turn reduced nesting sites as well prey species abundance, leading to declining shrike numbers. To cap it off, rats and cats were both introduced to the island and are major predators of eggs and chicks, reducing nesting success and slowing population recovery.
Do San Clemente Loggerhead Shrikes have any interesting courtship behaviors?
Oh, yes! Shrikes are songbirds with an array of songs and displays as part of their courtship. Males sing to attract a female to their territory, but first a female will often take up residence on the periphery of his territory. My mentor used to say that the perfect female SCI Shrike is a slug on a stick. She will sit planted at the territory border while the male sings, displays, shows off nest sites, and feeds her to the point that she spits out or caches all food offerings. Finally she will move on to his territory and they will sing together and begin nest building.

Thanks to SFBBO board member Christine Zack for answering these questions. She spent 3+ years studying the captive breeding behaviors of these shrikes. This captive breeding and reintroduction project is one of the most successful avian restoration projects to date!

Feather molt

Feathers are a defining feature of modern birds and serve many functions including flight, insulation, camouflage, and display.
Because feathers are so important, they need to be replaced typically once each year depending on the bird species and particular feather. The process of feather replacement is called molt.

​
In the left photo, notice the very worn primary (outer edge) feathers of the Nashville Warbler and the new feathers coming in. In the middle photo, compare the fresh feathers of the hatch year Audubon’s Warbler to the worn feathers of the adult (right photo)!

Nashville Warbler wing showing molting feathers
Wing of hatch-year Audubon's Warbler
Wing of adult Audubon's Warbler

In most temperate-zone songbirds, adults molt after the breeding season in late summer and fall. Some species even migrate to a specific place to complete the molt before continuing migration. This is called molt migration, and it’s apparently more common for species in western than in eastern North America. One example of molt migration is of Orange-crowned and Nashville Warblers migrating to high elevation meadows in the Sierra Nevada for a few weeks before continuing south to Mexico!

​Left: Hatch-year Orange-crowned Warblers move up to higher elevation meadows in the Sierras to molt all the body feathers, including the greater wing coverts as shown here, but usually no flight feathers.
Right: Bad hair day for an Orange-crowned Warbler. This happens when they molt many of the body feathers simultaneously.

Molting Orange-crowned Warbler
Orange-crowned Warbler wing
How do young birds thermoregulate when they lose their downy feathers?
When young birds are replacing their first coat of downy feathers with full feathers, they are still being incubated or brooded by the adults. So they rely on the parents for thermoregulation during that stage. In most songbirds, the fledglings don’t leave the nest until their first full set of feathers (juvenal plumage) is complete. The juvenal plumage (and all subsequent plumages) includes down feathers under the contour feathers.
How often do most birds molt?
Typically once each year, and some individual feathers are replaced twice a year. Most songbirds have a complete molt after the nesting season and replace all feathers over the course of 4-8 weeks. Larger species like some hawks and albatrosses don’t have time to replace all feathers every year, so some of their feathers, especially flight feathers, may last longer than one year.
Do molted feathers ever get reused for other purposes?
Many species will use feathers to line nests, and some species are more likely to use feathers from other species than from themselves. One example is Tree Swallows have a remarkable ability to find white chicken feathers. Humans use feathers for many applications but usually pluck birds to get them rather than collect them after molt.
Are there differences in molt patterns between feathers with more melanin vs. feathers with other types of pigmentation?
No differences of this type that I know of but in the spring many songbirds have a limited pre-alternate molt in which they replace some feathers around the head for what used to be called “breeding plumage”. So in that sense the molt is related to color but not necessarily melanin vs other pigments. Feathers with melanin tend to be black or brown and are usually more resistant to abrasion than feathers without melanin. This can be seen in woodpecker feathers in which the white spots wear down faster than the black parts.

Thanks to SFBBO Lead Biologist Dan Wenny for answering these questions.

California delta hypersalinity

The California Delta extends over 1,000 square miles from the western edge of the Central Valley to Suisun Bay, where the Sacramento and San Joaquin rivers join the greater SF Bay. As one of the largest estuaries in N. America, the Delta is a key stop for migratory birds traveling the Pacific Flyway and provides habitat for hundreds of species, including many endemic and endangered populations.

But the Delta is also threatened by land reclamation, agricultural practices, water diversions, and urban growth—all of which have disturbed its delicate balance of fresh- to brackish water. Dams, levees, and water diversions have steadily decreased the delta’s freshwater inflow, increasing the ratio of brackish to freshwater and diminishing the ability of the Delta tides to flush out salts and pollutants. This has significant consequences for the environment, economy, and public health, impacting both humans and the natural world.

The Delta has 5 major freshwater tributaries—the Sacramento, San Joaquin, Mokelumne, Cosumnes, and Calaveras rivers—which account for nearly half of the annual snowmelt and runoff in all of California. As these waterways move west towards the SF Bay, they mix with salt water from the Pacific Ocean, creating a delicate balance of saline and freshwater that forms the basis for healthy marsh habitats and biodiversity. When this balance is disrupted, hypersalinity “hotspots” emerge, as salts settle in narrow Delta channels without sufficient drainage. Some salts can even be drawn into pumps and transported farther inland to areas less adapted to salt-intrusion—like the San Joaquin and Tulare Lake Basins—where hypersalinity poses an even more severe ecosystem threat.

What bird species rely on the Delta year-round?
Hundreds! The California Delta offers a diverse array of habitats -- including agricultural land, urban settlements, riparian areas, brackish marshlands, and wetlands -- and remarkable biodiversity, making it a great spot for all kinds of birds, from falcons and corvids to sparrows and swallows. The Delta is even home to several endemic species and subspecies, including the Suisun Song Sparrow and the Saltmarsh Common Yellowthroat. In addition to supporting migratory and year-round populations, the Delta also offers critical habitat to many wintering and breeding bird populations. The large expanse of regularly-flooded agricultural lands allow the Delta to support a rich wintering bird community including Swainson’s Hawks, Tundra Swans, Sandhill Cranes, Short-eared Owls, White-faced Ibis, Greater White-fronted Geese, and thousands of dabbling ducks, among others.
What are some of the endangered or threatened species that live in the Delta?
Most of the endangered / threatened species of the Delta are aquatic species, which are particularly threatened by increases in ambient salinity. These include the Delta and Longfin Smelts, Green Sturgeon, CA Tiger Salamander, Sacramento Splittail, CA Red-Legged Frog, at least four types of shrimp, and multiple salmon species. The list of threatened species in the Delta also includes small mammals (Salt Marsh Harvest Mouse, Riparian Brush Rabbit, Riparian Woodrat), reptiles (Giant Garter Snake), birds (CA Least Tern and CA Ridgway’s Rail), butterflies (Lange’s Metalmark), and several plants (Suisun Thistle, Contra Costa Wallflower, Antioch Dunes Evening Primrose).
How do dams and water diversion programs disrupt water flow to the Delta?
Hundreds of dams, reservoirs, canals, and aqueducts have already been built in the Delta and Central Valley watersheds, from federally-sponsored water projects like the New Melones Dam and Contra Costa Canal, to state- and locally-sponsored ones like the O’Shaughnessy Dam (in Hetch Hetchy Valley) and the North Bay Aqueduct. Of the dozens of rivers that flow through CA, only one is completely undammed (the Smith River, on CA’s North Coast near the Oregon border). These projects were completed for myriad reasons, but all of them heavily manipulate the Delta’s upstream watershed, diminishing its freshwater inflow and increasing its ratio of brackish to freshwater. Within the Delta, freshwater is further diverted through CA’s largest water projects: the Central Valley Project (CVP) and the State Water Project (SWP). Both employ enormous water pumps in the southeastern Delta to facilitate freshwater export which, over time, have altered the flow of the Delta tides by forcing water to flow from north to south, rather than following its natural course from east to west. This severely diminishes the Delta’ ability to naturally flush out salts and other pollutants, threatening habitat, biodiversity, and human health.
Are there any major private or public initiatives that are addressing the problem of hypersalinity in the Delta?
Yes! Per state legislation passed in 1992, protecting, restoring, and enhancing the Delta ecosystem is now a “co-equal” priority with providing a reliable water supply for agricultural and urban use (an improvement from no priority). State and local leaders have since attempted a variety of regulatory methods to promote the ecological vitality of the Delta and lessen the impacts of hyper-salinization. In 2009, the Delta Stewardship Council was created to oversee a comprehensive, long-term, legally enforceable plan to guide management of the Delta’s resources and manage the state’s “co-equal goals”. Importantly, the state has also implemented seasonal, place-based fresh water and salinity objectives which dictate the Delta’s export and inflow ratios, river flows, outflow for habitat preservation, salinity content, and local water quality standards. The Delta has also been recognized for protection by the CA Bays and Estuaries Policy, and by its designation in 2019 as a National Heritage Area. Many private groups and environmental non-profits are working to protect the Delta from ecosystem threats like hypersalinity, and additional organizations are actively fighting some of the underlying problems (e.g. the damming of CA’s rivers and the consequent diversion of the Delta’s freshwater tributaries, destruction of marsh habitat, etc.)

Thanks to SFBBO Science Outreach Intern Charlotte Diamant for answering these questions.

Marbled murrelets

Marbled Murrelets are endangered seabirds that spend most of their time in marine environments, but they rely on old growth redwood and Douglas fir forests to breed in California.

They don’t really build nests; they just lay their egg in a depression of mossy material on a flat platform created by a large branch. This is why large mature trees are important habitat for the species. They only lay one egg per nest, and typically only lay one nest per year. There’s a lot invested in that single egg, so it’s incredibly important to protect every nest in our area!

The Midpeninsula Regional Open Space District protects Marbled Murrelets by maintaining mature forest so these birds have habitat to breed in and by restricting activities that cause disturbance and noise during their breeding season. Midpen scientists also conduct audio-visual surveys and use Acoustic Recording Units to detect where murrelets are in the preserves and which flyways they might be using. 

​
Thank you to guest scientist Karine Tokatlian for answering these questions.

Do males and females split incubation and chick-rearing duties, or does one fly back and forth from the ocean bringing fish?
Male and female Marbled Murrelets diligently share duties. One adult will incubate the single egg for a 24-hour period while the other forages at sea, meeting at the nest at dawn to switch roles. The incubating adult stays motionless and well camouflaged in the nest. The chick is only brooded by the adults for 1-2 days after hatching, after which it will remain in the nest by itself and wait quietly for the adults to return with food. Adults fly from the coast or nearby foraging grounds to the nest and present a fresh fish to the developing chick, which swallows it whole. Fish exchanges can occur up to 8 times a day!
What is the estimated number of Marbled Murrelets nests sites in Midpen preserves this spring/summer?
We're still monitoring our Preserves this season and haven't confirmed active nest sites at this time. However based on audio and visual data from past years, there is a strong potential for murrelets to be in habitat patches within Purisima Creek Redwoods and El Corte de Madera Open Space Preserves.
Do Marbled Murrelets migrate?
Information on Marbled Murrelet migration is limited, but generally, murrelets remain within their breeding range year-round where they spend the winter in nearshore marine waters. The population is concentrated in Alaska and British Columbia where they make small-scale movements between coastal, inland, and southern waters.  Long-distance migrations occur mostly from northern breeding grounds to southern areas. Some venture to the waters of Southern California and they’ve been documented as far south as northern Mexico, nearly 760km south of their breeding range in California.

How can you help? If you visit Midpen Preserves with murrelet habitat (Purisima Creek Redwoods OSP, El Corte de Madera OSP, and portions of La Honda Creek OSP), remember to pack out your trash and food scraps!

Protecting wildlife on Midpen Preserves - clean up food waste and trash, and never feed wildlife
Bird-building collisions

Collisions with buildings are estimated to cause up to 1 billion bird deaths each year in the US. The main reason birds fly into buildings is glass: glass can act as mirrors, reflecting the sky and trees, and may appear to many birds as continuous habitat. Transparent windows can also appear to be clear pathways for birds to fly through, especially when habitat is visible on the other side. For these reasons, glass near vegetation is especially dangerous, and artificial light at night worsens the problem by drawing birds near buildings.

Some birds are more vulnerable to collisions with buildings than others. Most victims of collisions are nocturnally migrating birds, such as warblers, flycatchers, and sparrows, but other birds like hummingbirds are also vulnerable. Recent research shows that forest birds and insect-eating migrants are especially susceptible to collisions. As many of these species are in decline for a variety of reasons, a great way to help birds is by making windows more visible, such as by using fritted glass or applying patterns to glass.

How do you get birds to stop flying into windows? We have tall windows near trees and frequent (weekly) collisions.
Unfortunately, it is likely that the trees are a huge factor in the frequency of window collisions;  the birds are probably seeing the reflected trees in the windows. If you are able to, trim the trees closest to the windows and ensure that there are no attractants, like feeders and lights, near the windows. Using tightly placed visual markers on the exterior of the windows will help reduce the likelihood of collisions (~2 inches apart horizontally if collisions are frequent). Examples include suspended cord/rope, decals, and dot grids, and you can use DIY options or professionally manufactured materials. Adding a screen or netting to the outside of the window can also help birds safely bounce off instead of colliding with the glass.
What are the cheapest and most effective ways to deter birds from hitting windows?
You can try keeping curtains and blinds closed to help turn your open window into a wall or a barrier. However, depending on the time of day and the amount of light bouncing off the window, the glass can still be reflective on the outside, so this method may not work well for all windows at all times of the day. Removing bird feeders near problematic windows and keeping your lights off or closing blinds/shades after dark will also help, as some birds are attracted to light sources. Other effective, inexpensive, temporary options include DIY solutions like suspending paracord from the windows or adding patterns (dots, lines, or even drawings) using a paint pen, tempera paint, or masking tape, ensuring that the patterns are applied to the exterior of the window and spaced no more than 2-4 inches apart.
What can be done about young birds hitting dotted windows?
Young birds are likely naive to the dangers of windows and less agile in flight, so they have more difficulty changing course if they’re heading toward a window. You can try making the dots larger so they are visible from farther away or adding dots closer together (~2 inches apart) which may help birds better perceive the glass as a barrier. Other ways to reduce the chances of collisions overall include clearing dense vegetation near problem windows and keeping bird feeders a safe distance away from the windows (closer than 3 feet or farther than 30 feet).
Any suggestions to prevent birds flying into a slate patio floor?
We’ve never heard of birds flying into a patio floor like this before. It’s possible that the smooth, dark surface can be mistaken for water (possibly due to polarized light signals or other visual cues). It’s unclear if this happens with birds, but bats can sometimes mistake smooth surfaces (like glass or metal) with water when they rely on echolocation. There may be some other factors at play here, and we would need more information to get a better sense of what’s happening. You can certainly try applying patterns (perhaps dots, lines, or drawings) with chalk or tape in a contrasting color to see if that helps -- we’d be interested to know what you find!

Thanks to SFBBO Biologist Anqi Chen and Environmental Education & Outreach Specialist Sirena Lao for answering these questions.

Polar bears

Polar bears are solitary but often communicate through scent as they have an amazingly well-developed sense of smell. Most bears have stable, established home ranges and use trees or other substrates to mark their territories and signal their availability to mate. However, polar bears can have a home range of 50,000 square miles, which changes year to year with sea ice formation. Their habitat is mostly snow and ice without trees and rocks to mark. So how do they find each other in this vast space to mate? It’s all in the feet and their tracks as they walk!

On average, female polar bears mate every 3 years. Ovulation is induced by mating. They have delayed implantation, which means they mate in spring but the embryo doesn’t grow until fall when she enters a maternity den. This also allows polar bears to mate, den, and give birth during times of year that are optimal for survival.

Polar bears have been observed sniffing tracks in snow and ice and following them for hundreds of miles to find a mate. Christine’s captive research showed that, using pedal scents, polar bears can distinguish between male and female bears as well as females in estrus versus those with cubs.

How long do polar bear cubs stay with their mother before venturing off on their own?
Polar bear cubs stay with their mothers for ~2.5 years or 30 months. They nurse for about 18 months, then spend time learning to hunt and survive from their mother.
Do polar bears hibernate?
Polar bears do not hibernate like other bear species do. Females create dens in snow drifts or sea ice to give birth and care for young cubs. They can spend 3-5 months in a den during which they enter a dormant state where their heart rate slows, but they do not continuously sleep. Additionally, her body temperature does not decrease as it would for hibernation.
If polar bears leave scents in their tracks, how is the scent produced? 
Do they have glands on their feet?
Yes, a dissection found that they have glands similar to what humans have in their armpit (apocrine glands) in their feet. The way that the scent is produced in polar bears has not been studied, but it may be similar to how we sweat and produce scents. 
Would a polar bear be attracted to honey, similar to their grizzly bear cousins?
Many captive polar bears enjoy treats that contain honey. Their arctic habitat makes encountering honey in the wild less likely, but they are attracted to human-made dumps and towns, often causing problems due to their interest in human food. As sea ice habitat shrinks, polar bear dependence on dumps/trash for food will likely increase, and there will be more human and polar bear interactions (which unfortunately often ends badly).

Thanks to SFBBO Board Member Christine Zack for answering these questions. She studied olfactory communication of polar bears via comparative captive tests for her Master’s while working for the San Diego Zoo’s Institute for Conservation.

Birding by ear

Birding by ear is a great way to find, identify, and understand the birds around us. Birds have two main types of vocalizations: songs and calls. Birds sing their full songs mostly in spring, during the breeding season. A bird’s song can be sweet, melodic, and long like an American Robin or it can be sharp and shrill like the kon-ka-ree of a Red-winged Blackbird. Birds use shorter calls, often just a “chip”, throughout the year to make contact with each other, sound an alarm that a predator is about, or communicate an individual’s location.

And vocalizations aren’t the only way we identify birds by ear. Birds make other recognizable sounds, such as the drumming of a Pileated Woodpecker as it fades in intensity, the toe-to-leaf scratching of a Spotted Towhee, the tail feather popping sound of an Anna’s Hummingbird, and the whistling wing noise of a Mourning Dove.

Birding by ear is a great way to find and identify hard to see birds like owls, rails, Wrentit and Horned Lark. And in some cases, vocalizations are the best way to distinguish two species, such as Eastern vs. Western Meadowlark.

The best way to start learning to bird by ear is to listen to the sounds of the birds you see each day, like the Black Phoebe.

Some birds are born with innate songs, while others learn to sing from their parents and neighbors. And some birds go even further and learn the songs of other birds. These are referred to as mimics and they can be tricky for birding by ear!

Steller’s Jays imitate Red-tailed Hawks, often very convincingly, to scare off other birds. European Starlings blend environmental sounds of goats, frogs, and traffic signals in with their own whistles and squeaks. But perhaps our best local mimic is the Northern Mockingbird. An adult male Mockingbird can string together up to 200 different songs, usually repeating each one many times before moving on to the next. We had a neighborhood Mockingbird who did a four-part car alarm that could barely be distinguished from the real thing!

How do you get better at identifying species with similar songs? And how do you distinguish similar calls?
Practice! Listen to recordings of each bird and compare them. What differences stand out to you? We like the iBird Pro and Merlin apps for this. Also, look at Spectrographs on eBird and see the differences in the songs visually.
Here are a few of our favorite ways to discern between birds that have similar songs: Song Sparrow and Bewick's Wren can be confusing. Song Sparrow starts with the same three notes then goes into a jumbly musical song. Bewick's Wren has a wind-up followed by a jumbly musical song ending with three or five of the same notes. California Scrub Jay and Steller's Jay both sound like jays, but Scrub Jay goes up. “Right??!!” Mnemonic is Scrub up! Steller's Jay goes shook shook shook.
Do only male birds sing?
No. It was assumed for a long time that only males did the singing. But we are getting better documentation that female birds sing too, especially birds of the tropics. It is known that female Orioles, Grackles, and Wrens sing. In our area that means Canyon Wren, Rock Wren, House Wren, Bewick's Wren, Great-tailed Grackle, Hooded Oriole, and Bullock's Oriole. And sometimes you can tell the male from the female by the song! We need more recordings of female birds singing to get a better understanding of which species have female songs. You can help by recording female bird songs and adding them to your eBird checklists. In your comments, enter the exact phrase: “Contributed for the female bird song project: femalebirdsong.org” 
For more information go to ebird.org/news/femalebirdsong17 and FemaleBirdSong.org.
What look-alike birds can you tell apart by sound?
Long-billed Dowitcher and Short-billed Dowitcher look very similar, but can be identified by call. Long-billed calls go Keek Keek Keek and Short-billed calls sound like Tu Tu Tu. T is next to S in alphabet, so Tu is Short-billed. K is next to L, so Keek is Long-billed. 
American Crow and Common Raven can be confusing visually, but a crow goes caw caw while a raven gives a deep raspy gronk.
Downy Woodpecker and Hairy Woodpecker are practically twins, but the Downy's whinny call goes down at the end. Downy = down.
What are the top 10 mnemonic devices you use to remember the songs for common NorCal birds?
1. Great Horned Owl: Who's awake? Me too.
2. Western Bluebird: Chew! flight call
3. Golden-crowned Sparrow: Sings a sad “Oh dear me” in descending notes.
4. Brown Creeper: Sings “Trees beautiful trees!”
5. Orange-crowned Warbler: Song is a trill that rises and falls over the top of the O of Orange.
6. American Goldfinch: Flight call is “Potato Chip” and it flies with a dip.
7. Caspian Tern sounds like cats being burned which rhymes with Caspian Tern.
8. Wilson's Warbler: Song is an accelerating and aggressive “Hey you kids get off my lawn!” like Mr. Wilson of Dennis the Menace.
9. California Quail: Some people say “Chi-ca-go!” but we like “Cui-da-do! because it means beware in Spanish.
10. Acorn Woodpecker: Some people say Jacob Jacob Jacob. We like Acorn, Acorn, Acorn!

It is thought that the more songs a Mockingbird can remember and sing, the more appealing it is as a mate. If you’ve ever had a bird singing all night long in your neighborhood, it was probably a lonely male Mockingbird displaying its mimicry skills in hopes of making a love connection.

Thank you to guest scientists Kitty O’Neil and Bill Pelletier for answering these questions.

soil

We often take the soil under our feet for granted, but soil is more than just a bunch of dirt! A key SFBBO effort is to restore habitats to support the local bird life we all love. Good restoration efforts begin with the soil. Soils are the place our food crops are grown, the support beneath our homes and businesses, the base for terrestrial plant life, a zone for cleansing and storing water, a critical medium for carbon and nitrogen cycles, and a home to wildlife such the Burrowing Owl. Some birds even need soil to get clean with a good roll in the dirt!

Soils are a key storage sink for some of the excess carbon in our atmosphere driving climate change, and they are the biologically active dynamic zone for supporting life. Did you know that a teaspoon of rich garden soil can contain up to one billion bacteria, several yards of fungal filaments, and several thousand protozoa?

Soil can make you happy – literally! Scientists found that a soil bacterium (M. vaccae) triggers the same serotonin-releasing neurons in the brain as Prozac. Feeling down? Get out and commune with some soil!

Soils come in all colors, from blue-green to brown to bright red. They can even develop in the canopy of massive redwoods. They are all ages, too; scientists recently found an ancient soil they estimate is 3.7 billion years old! Just like birds, soils are unique to their environment and have a classification system with common and scientific names too.

What can I do to help with compacted soil?
Add and incorporate organic matter! Ameliorating compaction takes organic matter, digging/tilling to incorporate it into the soil, and time. Ideally you would add 6-12” of good quality compost/mulch/peat to the surface and then incorporate it into the top 12-18” of soil (by shovel, rototiller etc). Adding organic matter to the surface without incorporation can help make slow incremental changes over time.

You can also grow a cover crop to be incorporated later. Using plant cover crops (legumes such as clovers, vetch, beans, and peas are great) or deep-rooted grasses like rye or buckwheat is a common means to improve soil. There are many trees that can survive in compacted soils as well, and you can check with a local nursery or cooperative extension service to find the tree best suited for your area. You just need to make sure you give the tree an appropriate planting hole to provide good root establishment. Finally, if there is an established lawn, you can mulch mow (leave grass clippings/mowed tree leaves on site).
How do wildfires affect forest and grassland soils?
Direct soil fire impacts include hydrologic changes, erosion, and ability of local plants and wildlife to thrive (food & shelter). The long-term effects on soil are dependent on the quantity and quality of surface organic matter that burns (think of that layer of old decomposed leaves, branches, and logs) and the fire intensity. Fire is a natural and necessary part of grassland and forest ecosystems. A low intensity fire can leave grass roots systems live and
intact and ultimately create a healthier soil. Based on what I’m hearing about our local forest fires, there will be a real mix of land that burned intensely and that which burned more lightly. Long-term, erosion is the biggest soil concern; you can’t replace lost soil. The other effects will ameliorate with time.
 
Key soil concerns after fire are soil erosion, hydrophobicity (certain organic compounds repel water and can coat the soil surface; when water can’t infiltrate into the soil, it increases the potential for erosion and decreases water availability for plants), nutrient release (organic matter is composed primarily of carbon, nitrogen and phosphorus, and depending on the severity of the burn, fire causes a loss or a pulse addition of available nutrients), loss of soil microorganisms and root mycorrhizae (fungal attachments critical for water and nutrient uptake for many trees), and effects on wildlife.
What causes the soil to create that fresh rain smell?
Geosmin is an organic molecule, C6H22O, generated by the soil bacterium Streptomyces that is that fresh, earthy after rain smell.

Petrichor is the actual name of that earthy smell. Humans have a great sensitivity to this smell, we can detect it at a parts-per-trillion level!

Another interesting fact is that some animals and insects use that geosmin scent to lead them to water!
How big of a problem is erosion and what are some ways to reduce it?
Soil erosion by water and wind is a large-scale problem of local and global concern that affects landscape health (ability to support vegetation & wildlife), ability to grow food crops, and water quality and quantity. A 2017 FAO report notes that 83 billion tons of soil are eroded from arable land each year! In addition to loss of soil fertility & arability, the addition of excess soil into waterways reduces water quality, impacting aquatic life and adding excess nutrients that can cause eutrophication (algae blooms that deplete oxygen).
To reduce erosion, don’t leave your soil bare. Keep the soil surface covered with organic matter, plants, or another permeable material as much as possible. Plant the appropriate grass/shrub/tree species that will hold the soil in place with their root systems. Mulches, both organic and non-organic (gravels, etc), help reduce erosion. Terracing and contour planting can be used in steeper terrain and larger scale settings.

Thanks to SFBBO Board Member Cristina Siegel for answering these questions. Cristina has worked on a High Sierra wilderness soil survey and as a USFS-Pacific Southwest Research Station soil scientist in Redding. Her research focused on soil compaction effects on tree growth, forest health, and soil-water-plant interactions

Purple martins

Purple Martins are the largest swallows in North America. They are more common on the east coast, but we have migratory and breeding populations in a narrow band here on the west coast. They are a Species of Special Concern in California due to declines in range and population size.

Purple Martins nest in cavities created by other species and also use birdhouses, gourds, or crevices of buildings or rocky cliffs. Native Americans would set up gourds for them, and birds began shifting to using artificial nest sites before colonization by Europeans. They have a long history of this co-habitation with humans, especially in eastern North America where almost all nest sites are provided by humans. In western North America, birdhouses and gourds seem less effective, and folks are encouraged to provide more natural habitats like tree snags and wooden poles. Eastern populations also prefer multi-compartment birdhouses, while western populations mostly use single-cavity houses, similar to those used by bluebirds and Tree Swallows.

The Midpeninsula Regional Open Space District works to conserve Purple Martins; 5-6 were observed at Mt Thayer (adjacent to Mt Umunhum) in Midpen’s Sierra Azul Open Space Preserve, and they were confirmed breeding in cavities in old wooden telephone/electricity poles. Their presence at Mt Thayer confirms that the Mt Umunhum area is the most important site in the Santa Cruz Mountains for Purple Martins.

In the Bay Area, when is the best time to see Purple Martins and where are some good spots?
PUMAs typically arrive in the Bay Area in April and remain to breed until late August. They’re also known to return to previous nesting sites, so visiting a known colony during this timeframe is your best chance of seeing them. PUMAs can fly and forage several kilometers from their nest site but they tend to be most active near their nests in the morning. Search eBird for locations of sightings nearest you.
They are uncommon so you’ll have to keep an eye out for their distinct metallic blue color and listen for their unique throaty song that some liken to R2D2. They have been recently seen near Half Moon Bay and Bonny Doon (impacted by wildfires, though this kind of disturbance ultimately can create habitat for PUMA). And Mt Umunhum of course! 
As I understand it, Purple Martins are pretty rare in the Bay Area. Was this always the case?
PUMAs are relatively rare in the Bay Area -- one of the reasons why the small population found at Mt Umunhum is so significant. Historically they were widely distributed in California in almost every habitat where cavities are available but they have localized populations. Based on historical records, PUMAs had only ever been uncommon and local in the Bay Area and were most frequently reported in areas with conifer forests (ex. Coastal ridges in Marin County and the Santa Cruz Mountains). They were seen nesting in Santa Cruz and in the Santa Cruz Mountains through the 1950s, and in Los Gatos in 1949.
What color(s) are the baby Purple Martins? How long until they get their purple color?
Baby PUMAs are reddish pink in color because they hatch with no down and their feathers don’t appear until they’re about 12 days old. Juveniles are overall drab, brown and grey in color with pale bellies. Both male and female birds will start to develop that distinctive metallic blue color in their first year, and males take 2 years to get entirely glossy purple.
Is there a nest box I can use to attract Purple Martins?
You can find nest box information here: 
https://nestwatch.org/learn/all-about-birdhouses/birds/purple-martin 
However, a strong caveat to note is that most nest box designs are geared toward east coast PUMAs. Our subspecies on the west coast appears to prefer single cavity boxes and, even more important, natural cavities whenever possible. Some state’s conservation goals are to provide natural habitat for PUMAs so they don’t become completely reliant on human-provided housing. I encourage folks to provide cavities for them in a natural way if that’s possible.

Midpen scientists set up nest boxes in the area to provide more habitat for Purple Martins, but so far have found no evidence of them being used. They are working on setting up different types of bird boxes, hoping that a different design will be more attractive to them to support this important population.

​Thank you to guest scientist Karine Tokatlian for answering these questions.

Monarch Butterflies

For several years, SFBBO board member Christine Zack has been a community scientist participating in the Monarch Thanksgiving and New Year’s counts in partnership with The Xerces Society, Monarch Joint Venture, and U.S. Fish and Wildlife Service. This year, the Western Monarch Count Thanksgiving Count runs from Saturday, November 14 to Sunday, December 6. The New Year’s Count runs from Saturday, December 26 to Sunday, January 10. These counts document overwintering monarchs at 240 sites along the coast of California this fall. Citizen scientists attend a training, are assigned a site, and record data via an app. Christine also participated in the migrating monarch and milkweed surveys at Don Edwards SF Bay National Wildlife Refuge in Alviso and Lake Cunningham, which help determine habitat availability and usage in California.

Historically, an estimated 4.5 million monarchs overwintered on the California coast. 2018 & 2019 counts were substantially lower than even just 2-3 years prior, when the population was ~200,000-300,000 butterflies. Volunteers reported 29,418 monarchs in 2019—less than 1% of the population in the 1980s. The number of overwintering monarchs in California continues to be ~30,000 monarchs—the minimum threshold estimate below which the population may collapse.

Want to help monarchs? Check out the The Xerces Society’s Western Monarch Call to Action and This is How You Can Help document. These actions will benefit monarchs and also support our many other native bees and butterflies—and birds!

I overheard a local say: 'looks like there won't be monarchs again this year'. What's up with that?
The monarch population is at a critical level in California. Last year only ~30,000 were counted and many sites surveyed that historically had monarchs had declined to 0. Monarchs need a cluster, so they will not overwinter at a site without other monarchs. Habitat loss, climate change, and pesticides are the main drivers of Western Monarch population decline. On Dec 15th the US Fish & Wildlife Service will decide if the monarch will be federally listed as an endangered species.
What kind of plants do monarchs use when they’re butterflies?
Monarchs are attracted to many nectar plants to feed on. In general stick with California native nectar plants. Those recommended for attracting monarchs by the Xerces society include Coyotebrush, mulesfat, desert broom, pacific asher, goldenrod, sunflowers, willow, and golden bush. Milkweed is the monarch host plant needed for reproduction.
How do I plant milkweed to help monarchs?
Milkweed is the plant most often associated with monarchs because they lay their eggs on milkweed and begin as caterpillars one them. If you choose to plant milkweed, showy and narrowleaf are the suggested species for Northern California. Seed for both is easily found and can be grown in your yard or a pot. Finding a small starter plant at a native plant sale or nursery is also a good way to start. Milkweed will spread its seed year after year and come back on its own after it dies off in winter. So don’t pull up the plant in winter, just trim it back. Avoid tropical milkweed as it blooms at the wrong time of year which can harm monarchs and they are more associated with parasites.
Why are they showing up so late in the Bay Area and other parts of CA this year? Will these late arrivers survive to become butterflies?
Monarchs receive their signal to begin migrating from two observable factors: 1) the shortening of days as the season changes from summer, to fall, to winter, and 2) the dying-off of milkweed. Milkweed doesn’t die off until fall weather gets cold, so as climate change brings us milder and milder fall weather, monarchs are thought to be delayed as they stay and reproduce at milkweed sites. Later migrating butterflies are thought to be less likely to survive as they encounter harsher weather conditions en route.

Thanks to SFBBO board member Christine Zack for answering these questions.

This program was possible thanks to a grant from the Midpeninsula Regional Open Space District.
Donate
  • Facebook
  • Twitter
  • Instagram
  • YouTube

San Francisco Bay Bird Observatory ● PO Box 610578, San Jose, CA 95161 ● 408-946-6548 ● info@sfbbo.org